Indicate in the comments whether you'd like to sign this letter as a supporter of the Committee for the Advancement of Scientific Skepticismat the Center for Inquiry (Canada). Include your name, title, and affiliation. Email me if you'd rather not post a comment. (My name is "l.moran" and my domain is "utoronto.ca")
See Shame on the Royal Ontario Museum for more information about the event.
William Thorsell
Director, the Royal Ontario Museum
100 Queen's Park
Toronto, ON
M5S 2C6
Mr. Thorsell,
We at the Committee for the Advancement of Scientific Skepticism (CASS) at the Centre for Inquiry (Canada) and its supporters were dismayed to learn that the Royal Ontario Museum will be sponsoring a talk by Deepak Chopra at the University of Toronto in connection with the Director's Signature Series: The Warrior Emperor and China's Terracotta Army.
While we fully support the concept of academic freedom, we are baffled by this invitation and wonder how it fits into the mandate of the museum to "serve as an advocate for science in the study of nature," as stated in your message on the ROM website. Mr. Chopra's new age psycho-babble may be attractive to the general public, but by inviting him to speak at the ROM, you lend undeserved scientific credibility to his pseudo-scientific claims about quantum physics, psychology, chemistry and medicine. These claims are rightly rejected as absurd by the scientific community and by promoting them you tarnish the otherwise excellent scientific reputation of the Royal Ontario Museum.
CASS will be publishing the standard rebuttals of Deepak Chopra's fanciful quackery in order to help the public understand where he goes off the rails. Our hope is to turn this otherwise embarrassing event into a learning opportunity. We are also contacting the sponsors of the event and the ROM's other private donors in order to voice our concern about Mr. Chopra's presentation. We would like the ROM to clarify how Mr. Chopra's visit fits into this lecture series, as it seems this is just another opportunity for him to promote his new book.
We look forward to hearing from you.
Sincerely,
The Committee for the Advancement of Scientific Skepticism (CASS) at the Centre for Inquiry Canada
Larry, I'll sign that.
ReplyDeleteGabriel A. Devenyi B.Eng.
Ph.D. Student - Engineering Physics
McMaster University
Excellent letter, well written and succinct.
ReplyDeleteCount me in.
ReplyDeletePZ Myers
Associate Professor, Division of Science and Math
University of Minnesota Morris
As a Torontonian, I find this deeply embarrasing. Please cancel the quack show.
ReplyDeleteJanice in Toronto
I'll Sign that, too.
ReplyDeleteDarren S. A. George, PhD
Instructor, Math/Science
North Island College
Campbell River, B.C.
Add my name if you wish:
ReplyDeleteLarry Flowers
Microbiologist
I'd sign.
ReplyDeleteJoel Green
lowly Toronto resident
I would be more than willing to be included on this.
ReplyDeleteTravis D. Stewart, BSc, BCS
MCS Student - Computer Science (Bioinformatics)
Carleton University
Michelle Noël, MA (University of Toronto)
ReplyDeleteresident of Ontario
I'll definitely sign this:
ReplyDeleteEric J. Pedersen
Ph.D. student - Biology
McGill University
I'll get behind this.
ReplyDeleteBenjamin Wilson
M.A. Student - Physical Anthropology
Northern Illinois University
Andrew Connor
ReplyDeleteToronto, ON
Leave my colobus monkeys alone Deepak!
Larry
ReplyDeleteI have no title but I will sign it.
Susan Benfold
Bolton, Ontario
Great letter, sign me up.
ReplyDeleteMary Thomson
Director of Applications Development
Remspec Corporation
Sign me up.
ReplyDeleteMaxine Levine
Toronto, ON
Put me down as well.
ReplyDeleteKevin Bailey
Chemical Engineering Student
University of Waterloo
I am a lifelong Toronto resident who has always loved the ROM. The decision to host this event is baffling and disappointing, to say the least.
ReplyDeleteAlyssa H.
Add me too.
ReplyDeleteAnthony Karosas, BA, BSc
Alberta Health Services
Edmonton, Alberta, Canada
Add my name.
ReplyDeleteNigel Gomm
Paris, Ontario
Trent Toulouse
ReplyDeletePh.D. Student Psychology
McMaster University
Add my signature.
ReplyDeleteA. Nowaczek
Haileybury ON
Me too!
ReplyDeleteMarcus Hill, PhD
Senior Lecturer in Mathematics Education
Liverpool John Moores University
Yes please, add me. Deepak's statements about anything "quantum" are frequently contradicted by my basic coursework in physical chemistry, instrumental analysis, etc. It's as if he never touched a single chemistry textbook.
ReplyDeleteBrian Brauchler
Senior Chemistry undergraduate
Case Western Reserve University
Cleveland, OH
Sign my name as well.
ReplyDeleteRandy Tyson
Research Council Officer
National Research Council of Canada
"Me too"
ReplyDeleteDeepak Chopra is fine for a museum of hoaxes, but not a museum of REALITY.
Sign me up. Clifford William Beninger , Ph.D. Biology (Chemical Ecology), currently acting as independent consultant.
ReplyDeleteI'll sign the letter also.
ReplyDeleteLyle D. Sanders
Virginia Beach, VA, USA
Signed
ReplyDeleteTrevor Hill
Parry Sound, Ontario.
I'll sign it too
ReplyDeleteJoel Hart
University of Calgary dropout
All around good guy
Signed.
ReplyDeleteEric Verspoor
Skeptic & Canadian embarrassed by this mess with The venerable ROM and woo-meister Deepak Chopra.
Please cancel the show.
I love the ROM, but I don't love this.
ReplyDeleteMatthew Dawydchak
resident of Toronto
Jeff Satterley
ReplyDeletePhD Student
Northeastern University
Boston, MA, USA
Oh, I totally support this.
ReplyDeleteRebecca Miller
Ph.D. Student - Genetics
University of Georgia
I'm in. Spent a lot of time in Toronto, great city and the museum needs to sort itself out.
ReplyDeleteAndy, Manchester
Signed.
ReplyDeletePK Jeaiem
MSc EE
Denmark
Er, the letter. Not Chopra.
ReplyDeleteRebecca Miller
Ph.D. Student - Genetics
University of Georgia
I would like to add my name to this letter:
ReplyDeleteAmy Brown
ROM Member
Ben Haller
ReplyDeletePh.D. student, Evolutionary Biology
McGill University
If non-scientists can sign on, please include me:
ReplyDeleteIan W. Hill
artist, supporter of CASS
Brooklyn, NY USA
Absolutely,
ReplyDeleteRyan Whitmarsh
Microbiology PhD student
University of Pennsylvania
This we don't need
ReplyDeleteI'll sign this
ReplyDeleteJohn Burt
Saskatoon, Saskatchewan
Signed, sealed, and delivered
ReplyDelete-Michael Spear
I'm also titleless but this is serious b.s.
ReplyDeleteBrent Morris
Toronto, ON
Me too, Larry.
ReplyDeletePeter Moulton
Phoenix, Arizona
Love you ROM, but what was the rationale behind supporting this nut?
ReplyDeleteMatthew Orr
Mathematical Physics Student
University of Waterloo
I'll sign as well
ReplyDeleteSarah Guermond
Biology student
University of Texas at Austin
Sign me up:
ReplyDeleteDr Martin Lee
Post-doctoral Researcher - Chronic Diseases
Ottawa Hospital Research Institute/University of Ottawa
Hell, I'll sign too.
ReplyDeleteRoberto A. Valenzuela, J.D.
2010 Vernon L. Smith Fellow of Law and Economics, Chapman University
Flavio Antenucci
ReplyDeleteApplication Developer
Toronto, Ontario
Thank you for this, Dr Moran and CASS. While a museum may reasonably present topics of both scientific and socio-cultural interest, Deepak Chopra's pseudoscience and anti-science belong in neither category. Except perhaps in a forum - including REAL scientists - to show how easily the ignorant and gullible are deluded.
ReplyDeleteDr. Sowmya Dakshinamurti (MD)
Winnipeg, MB
me too
ReplyDeleteGrant Wickman B.Sc, M.Sc (UofA)
Ph.D Student - Medicine
University of Glasgow
Dr. L. Jonathan Dursi
ReplyDeleteCanadian Institute for Theoretical Astrophysics
University of Toronto
I'll get on board--- I can't stand quantum woo being validated like that.
ReplyDeleteChristopher Granade
Masters Student in Theoretical Physics, Perimeter Scholars International
University of Waterloo
I support the Committee for the Advancement of Scientific Skepticism.
ReplyDeleteMichiel Duvekot
Toronto
Michael Kubillus
ReplyDeleteI'm definitly with you.
S.C. Kavassalis
ReplyDeleteUniversity of Toronto, Department of Physics
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteDamn right I will.
ReplyDeleteMike Eheler
Los Angeles, CA
C. Ryan Shannon
ReplyDeleteTulsa, OK
Absolutely.
ReplyDeleteColin Jagoe
Instructional Leadership Consultant - Science and Technology
Kawartha Pine Ridge District School Board
Francisco Rabang, IV
ReplyDeletetriOS College
Toronto, Ontario
Count me in.
ReplyDeleteRicardo A.Saenz
Research Professor
Facultad de Ciencias - University of Colima
Mexico
Douglas Crews
ReplyDeleteB.S., UC San Diego
You have my support.
ReplyDeleteEarl Lyon
Fredericton
New Brunswick
I'll sign!
ReplyDeleteJerry D. Harris
Associate Professor/Director of Paleontology
Physical Sciences Department
Dixie State College of Utah
Rosemary J. Redfield
ReplyDeleteProfessor, Dept. of Zoology
University of British Columbia
I agree with the above comments!
ReplyDeleteBob Barratt, RN BSN, MSc
Nurse Anesthetist
Stillwater, MN
I`ll certainly sign.
ReplyDeleteScott Shannon
BSc(Eng) Engineering Physics - Queen`s University
Count me in:
ReplyDeleteJohn Scanlon
Palaeontologist
Riversleigh Fossil Centre
Mount Isa QLD Australia
Hope ROM learns something from this.
ReplyDeleteSigned,
Vaibhav Prakash, PhD student-Theoretical Physics,Massey University,New Zealand.
Me too.
ReplyDeleteAndrew Nelson
Geoscientist
Sydney
NSW
Australia
Chopra's continual and demonstrably false statements about....well just about everything...are an embarrassment and he should not be offered a platform by real scientists.
ReplyDeleteI'm not a scientist (though I'll be going back to school for my physics degree soon) so I'm not sure how much weight my name will add (or if my name will be added at all). But count me in:
Jason DeLaat
Montreal, Quebec, Canada
Here's a rare case for you: an artist against psuedoscience.
ReplyDeleteChris Felling
Victoria, British Columbia
I'm happy to sign this.
ReplyDeleteNelson Milum,
Calgary, Alberta
Count me in
ReplyDeleteTrevor Wilkes
Hamilton, Ontario family man
I'm in...
ReplyDeleteJill Mitchell Nielsen
MA Student - Interdisciplinary Graduate Studies in International Relations
University of British Columbia - Okanagan, Kelowna BC
Ashley F. Miller, MFA
ReplyDeleteLos Angeles, CA
And me.
ReplyDeletePaul Wilson, Ph.D
Computer Scientist
Austin, Texas USA
I'd like to sign this too.
ReplyDeleteYameen Huq
Undergrad- Chem Engineering
Georgia-Tech
I'll happily add my name to this growing list.
ReplyDeleteSean Sunley
University of Regina
Not a scientist either, but I love me some rational thinking.
ReplyDeleteEtienne Mallette
Literature teacher at Maisonneuve College
Mirabel, Quebec
Oy...can't believe this actually might happen. Deepak Chopra? Please. I'm in.
ReplyDeleteMatthew Miller
Grand Rapids, MI
I am ashamed that such a charlatan is given such a big platform. As a high school teacher, I teach my kids to think and use their judgment everyday. Hopefully, the ROM reconsiders.
ReplyDeleteSophie St-Pierre, Montreal,
Westmount High School,
English Montreal School Board
I'll sign.....
ReplyDeleteMichael J.A. Hamilton BSc, BEd, MD
Newmarket ON
Count me in
ReplyDeleteSteve Fines, MD
St. Cloud, MN
Count me in!
ReplyDeleteMiranda Gavrin, Indiana
I would like my name on this as well.
ReplyDeleteDavid Brue Brown
Disputanta, Virginia, USA
I'll sign that.
ReplyDeleteRobert Morrison
Edmonton, Alberta
I will sign that.
ReplyDeleteDean Buchanan
Count me in.
ReplyDeleteCameron Peters, MLSc
Science Instructor/Science Department Chair
Poulsbo, WA
I will sign this.
ReplyDeleteRobert DeCaire
M.Sc. student - Biology
University of Western Ontario
Please cancel this quack-show - something the ROM should not be seen to be endorsing.
ReplyDeleteLuke Tunmer
Director of Engineering
Qualcomm
Cambridge, UK.
(but a Canadian citizen).
I'll sign in on that one!
ReplyDeleteAndre Lessard,
University of Ottawa Student: Anthropology and Sociology
In.
ReplyDeleteAndrew H. Tripp
Soon-To-Be Honours Student at the University of Toronto
Count me in, too.
ReplyDeleteLauren Adasiak Cocilova
science-enthusiast and inhabitant of the reality-based community
Rochester NY USA
Please add me.
ReplyDeleteEmanuele Oriano, B.A., C.Tran.
Toronto, ON
Please include my signature.
ReplyDeleteSowmya N Rao
MS Student - Electrical Engineering
University of Southern California
Los Angeles, CA, USA
I'm in.
ReplyDeleteJames Croy
Victoria, BC
I will absolutely sign
ReplyDeleteIan Cromwell, MSc
BC Cancer Agency
Vancouver, BC
John M Holt
ReplyDeletePrincipal Research Scientist
Haystack Observatory
Massachusetts Institute of Technology
I'll sign that.
ReplyDeleteE.E. Ehrhardt
Senior Biochemistry undergraduate
Bowdoin College
Brunswick, Maine, USA
Count me in too.
ReplyDeleteDr. James Hartman
University of Texas
Count me in
ReplyDeleteBill Dileva
Scambusting! (on Facebook)
Windsor Ontario
I'll sign that,
ReplyDeleteMr Chopra and his quackery do not
belong in the ROM.
On the sidewalk outside with a hat, maybe.
Ian M Lommerse.
4th spruce tree over.
Yukon Terr.
Please add my signature:
ReplyDeleteSteven R. Fulton
Trenton, ON
Excellent letter. Please include my signature.
ReplyDeleteShari M. Jackson, MD
Neuroradiologist
Seattle, WA
Please add my signature to this list.
ReplyDeleteMichael Morgan
Director`s Circle Member of the Royal Ontario Museum
I'll sign that.
ReplyDeleteKyle Falcon
MA. Student - History
Wilfrid Laurier University
Me too.
ReplyDeleteRobert Allison
Professor, Computer Studies
Algonquin College
Happy to sign
ReplyDeleteJoy Kidd
Science Teacher
McKinney, Texas
It is important to let the museum know this guy is a fraud.
ReplyDeleteSign me up
I canceled my membership to the ROM because of this.
ReplyDeleteJohn Fruhwirth
B. Math ( Univ. of Waterloo)
Likewise; count me in:
ReplyDeleteAJ Milne
Ottawa
(Adding: the ROM is extremely unwise to lend unto that loon any credibility. The only legit way I could picture Chopra turning up in anything a responsible institution of that stripe might present would be as exhibit 'A' in a lecture on the popularity of quackery and pseudoscience, and how to spot the same.)
I support this letter.
ReplyDeleteKirsten MacKenzie, M.Sc., R.P.Bio.
Put down my signature.
ReplyDeleteHugh McBratney, M.Eng.
Toronto, Ontario.
Happily adding my name to the list.
ReplyDeleteDarren Olenick
Winnipeg, Manitoba
Megan Igo
ReplyDeleteProfessor of Biology
Merced College
Happy to sign.
ReplyDeleteDaryl LeBlanc
Senior Biology Teacher
Halton District School Board
I'll sign
ReplyDeleteAlix L. Reid, B.A. (honours), LL.B.
Duncan, B.C.
I can't stand Chopra. He is a disgrace to the medical profession. I'll be happy to sign.
ReplyDeleteJohn A. Yarzagaray M.D.
Chicago, IL
As a Canadian, I find this deeply distressing. Chopra's quantum quackery has nothing to do with science. I'll sign the letter.
ReplyDeleteStephen Ross
Red Deer, AB
Louise Tardif
ReplyDeleteCalgary, Alberta
I'll sign! I'm looking forward to bringing my Finnish friend to the ROM this summer - but I won't give them my money or support if they intend to pass it on to that guy.
ReplyDeleteJennifer Mulligan
B.Sc in biology from UWO
London, Ontario
Count me, too.
ReplyDeleteJim Last
Sacramento, CA
I'm in.
ReplyDeleteAndrew C. Holmes
St. John's, Newfoundland
You can count me in too.
ReplyDeletePaul McGrath
PhD student (Physics)
University of Waterloo
Oh, I'll certainly sign it.
ReplyDeleteChristopher L. Ogilvie, B.A. (Hons)
Juris Doctor Student
University of Toronto
Nathan Mellema, J.D.
ReplyDeleteSioux Falls, SD
Scott Johnson
ReplyDeleteScience student and teacher
Langley, BC, Canada
Count me in too.
ReplyDeleteJonathan Ridley
Newcastle, Uk
BA Phiolosophy dropout!
Sign my name on this, too.
ReplyDeletePeter Cook
Illustrator, science cartoonist
Toronto ON
Signed.
ReplyDeleteGregory Bieniek
Chicago, IL
Add my name too:
ReplyDeleteErik Davis
Toronto
I'd like to sign.
ReplyDeleteDr. James Wallis
Institute of Biological Chemistry
Washington State University
I will certainly add my name to this.
ReplyDeleteGarry J. VanGelderen
Retired Engineer
Penetanguishene, ON
Signed.
ReplyDeleteDonald Atkin
MSc student (Psychology)
U. of Alberta
My name as well, please.
ReplyDeleteMichael McCarron
B.A., RMT, B.Cool.
Whitby, Ontario.
I'll sign
ReplyDeleteMichael Heath
Science student, supporter, & opponent of woo
Gaylord, Michigan U.S.A.
I'm tempted to buy a ROM membership just to return it in disgust. Sign me up
ReplyDeleteAndrew Davidson
Toronto, ON
I'm in.
ReplyDeleteDon Cates (BSc U of Manitoba)
Retired medical research tech.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteIn:
ReplyDeleteRichard B. Hoppe, Ph.D.
retired Professor, Kenyon College, Ohio, USA.
I'll Sign,
ReplyDeleteLeith Jones,
Ontario resident.
I'm In,
ReplyDeleteGavin Sparby
Hibbing, MN
After thinking about this a bit I bet Larry just wants to get the real names of all of his readers. Everyone is outing themselves (including me) so it seems to be working.
ReplyDeleteI Concur
ReplyDeletePeter Harbison
Darwin
Australia
Include me in:
ReplyDeleteSharon Crawford
Madeira Park, BC
Cancel the invitation
ReplyDeleteKevin Keenan
PhD Student, QUB.
Put my name on that.
ReplyDeleteTravis S. Loosli PhD (Philosophy) EdS (School Psychology).
Count me in!
ReplyDeleteChristopher Mazur,
Kelowna, B.C.
I'm in too,
ReplyDeleteIan Simpson,
Ex-Toronto resident.
(Citizen of the universe,
and a gentleman to boot.)
Definitely Mr. Chopra should not be talking his usual unscientific new-age psycho babble at the ROM.
ReplyDeleteMr. Larry Gagnon, M.Sc.
Retired Petroleum Geologist
I'm in.
ReplyDeleteChris Roberts
Programmer
NF, Canada.
I'll sign that
ReplyDeleteDanny Keith James
Vancouver, B.C.
You can add me to the list of signatories.
ReplyDeleteAaron A. Heiss, M.Sc.
Ph.D. student in Evolutionary Biology
Dalhousie University
I loved their Darwin exhibit. This, not so much. I'm in.
ReplyDeleteAndrew Dunn
Saratoga NY
No title, but an occaisional patron of museums.
ReplyDeleteTrevor Zimmerman
Edmonton, AB
Count me in
ReplyDeletePablo Aran
Ph.D Student
Department of Chemistry
University of Cambridge
I'll sign too.
ReplyDeleteRyan C Herrington, Kitchener-Waterloo resident.
I'll sign
ReplyDeleteNick Gorton, MD, DABEM
Davis, CA
I'll sign too:
ReplyDeleteKim Sweeney
M.S. Cognitive Science
Graduate Student
UC San Diego
Wow. Definitely count me in.
ReplyDeleteShaun Wilson
Undergrad - Computer Science
University of New England
NSW Australia
Sheesh, you guys are so uptight. Now that Deepak gets a chance to raise your consciousness and expand your 'ways of knowing' the ROM will be able to lay on seminars about palmistry and phrenology around the fountain powered by the perpetual motion machine. Lit, of course, by power from cold fusion.
ReplyDeleteCount me in. No title, but I love museums, especially the ROM. My husband, children and I visit science museums frequently.
ReplyDeleteTiffany H. Cox
Des Moines, Iowa
Please Add my name:
ReplyDeleteKevin Jones
Calgary, Alberta
I'll Sign
ReplyDeleteBrian Crockett
SW Developer
You may add my name.
ReplyDeleteBarbara A. Meissner
Archaeologist
University of Texas at San Antonio
I still can still barely believe he was considered.
ReplyDeleteJosh Triska
PhD Student, Electrical Engineering
Oregon State University
Please include my signature on this letter. Deepak Chopra's pseudoscientific nonsense undermines the credibility of this respectable institution.
ReplyDeleteDavid Donald, P. Eng
Winnipeg
Robert B Brown
ReplyDeleteElectrical Engineer, Retired
Lexington KY USA
I will sign:
ReplyDeleteYuriy Zubarev,
Software Engineer,
Vancouver, BC
Benjamin Odenheimer
ReplyDeleteUndergraduate, St. John's College Santa Fe
Sasha Ramani
ReplyDeleteCandidate for BBA, BMath
University of Waterloo
Wilfrid Laurier University
Count me in too!
ReplyDeleteSteve Gibb
Maplewood, NJ
Please add my humble signature.
ReplyDeleteNancy Holst
Mother of 6
Promoter of Science and Reason
Chicago, Illinois
The ROM had a tremendous influence on me in my youth, and I am dismayed that it is appearing to pander to the ignorant with this invitation.
ReplyDeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteRichard Prins
ReplyDeleteMontréal, Canada
Count me in, too. Keep up the good fight CASS and CFI.
ReplyDeleteDavid Roscoe
North Bay, Ontario
As a Canadian, I am embarrassed by this. Sign me up.
ReplyDeleteJoseph W. Brown
Ph.D. Student, Ecology & Evolutionary Biology
University of Michigan
Please add my name.
ReplyDeleteStephanie Hevenor
Laboratory Instructor
Nipissing University
I'll definitely sign that.
ReplyDeleteMichael D. Barton
ReplyDeletePortland, OR
Greg Laden
ReplyDeleteI'll sign that.
ReplyDeleteRoger Hoffmore
Professional Geologist and Educator
California
Mark Propp
ReplyDeleteWinnipeg, Manitoba
I'll sign
ReplyDeletePeter A Hasek
MS, Physics
Certified Business Manager
Project Management Professional
Commerce Township, MI
From the Pacific North West and worried about the state of fluff brained non-arguments being promoted as "truths". Science FTW!
ReplyDeleteCameron Coale
Everett, Wa
I would love to sign it. I hope to major in Biology once I transfer.
ReplyDeleteJohn Capilos
Columbia, SC
Sign me on!
ReplyDeleteAndrew Rihn
BA, Kent State University
I'll gladly add my signature. Deepak Chopra is a snake oil salesman of the highest order.
ReplyDeleteI'll sign it gladly.
ReplyDeleteJohn Melby
Emeritus Professor of Music
University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign
I fully agree with and support your letter protesting the Royal Ontario Museum's invitation to Deepak Chopra. This kind of non-science nonsense does not belong in such institutions.
ReplyDeleteIan Wood
Austin, Texas USA
Tim Falkenberg
ReplyDeleteWhitehorse, Yukon
Al McDonell
ReplyDeleteCommon Sense
I'll sign that...
ReplyDeleteDarin Cowan, BSc
Ottawa, Ontario
Please include me on the petition
ReplyDeleteAnd the list keeps growing. Count me in.
ReplyDeleteBrian Thompson
Aurora, Ontario
Gary A Gabbard
ReplyDeleteCincinnati Ohio